NORA Study Tests Renewable Diesel/Biodiesel Heating Oil Blends

NORA Study Tests Renewable Diesel/Biodiesel Heating Oil Blends

LANCASTER, Pa. – A recent field study of renewable diesel/biofuel blends in the U.S. Northeast suggests that they may be a solution to offering fuel flexibility as states and municipalities continue to look toward lower carbon energy solutions, according to panelists at the Pennsylvania Petroleum Association Fall Energy Conference and Annual Meeting last week.

Together with other fuels, diesel fuel serves a key role in heating in the U.S. Northeast. The U.S. Census House Heating Fuel statistics for 2024 American Community Survey data estimated 52% of occupied housing units in Pennsylvania used natural gas for their primary source of heating, while 26% used electricity and 13% used fuel oil/kerosene.

The National Oilheat Research Alliance recently conducted its Field Study — Conversion of Oil-Fired Heating Systems to 100% Renewable Fuel. Industry participants and NORA representatives at the conference discussed their experiences and study results.

According to a NORA report, the study included 121 sites in Pennsylvania and Massachusetts and examined the use of 80% renewable diesel blended with 20% biodiesel (RD80/B20) and 50% renewable diesel/50% biodiesel (RD50/BD50) blends, spanning 18 months including two winter heating oil seasons.

The blends were used in a variety of heating appliance types, including boilers, furnaces and water heaters.

For the purposes of the study, Chevron provided the renewable diesel and biodiesel at prices on par with the cost of petroleum-based heating oil.

Pipeline shipments of these blends are not yet available to the Northeast.

Jason Lawrence, Senior Business Development Executive at Chevron, noted that after some initial logistical challenges were overcome and railcar transportation was established to Pennsylvania, the experience went well.

In a comment to OPIS, Chevron said “the study was successful showing heating oil with a range of RD/BD in the real world. Chevron and others in our industry have an off-the-shelf answer for heating oil that has worked for 121 sites – with existing infrastructure and without ripping out existing residential and commercial heating systems to replace them.”

While policy-enabled markets like LCFS programs and mandates could accelerate the process, Lawrence told OPIS that he has seen an overall steady increase in appetite for the use of biodiesel and renewable diesel in transportation and heating in the Northeast.

Panelists from Rhoads Energy, Oehlert Bros., Inc. and D.E. Duffy and Sons noted that their customers were excited to try the blends and readily agreed to participate in the field study.

Kate Duffey, HVAC Manager at D.E. Duffey and Sons, highlighted that customers did nothing to prepare their tanks for the fuel, they just used their equipment as it was.

Looking at the full study, NORA’s report did note that at four out of the 121 sites, the burner primary controls were upgraded to accommodate lower luminosity.

Michael DeBerdine, CEO of Rhoads Energy, Steve Oehlert of Oehlert Bros., and Duffey all noted that they received no negative feedback from their customers and saw no change in service rates, including for one tank that was roughly 70 years old.

Dr. Thomas A. Bucher, Technical Director at NORA, said that service statistics can be tough to get but that they did not see a statistical difference in rates. The report notes that combustion performance with the test blends was within specifications with the exception of three sites where corrective measures were taken, and that there was no recurrence at those sites.

The study did show that higher rates of head coking were found in “cold chamber” appliances (those with no refractory lining in the combustion chamber) while “hot chamber” appliances saw nominal head coking. NORA does not expect a long-term head coking concern if burners are serviced in accordance with manufacturers’ instructions.

Looking at the bigger picture, DeBerdine noted that this effort was important in preparing for the future. Michael Devine, NORA president, pointed to evolving regulations, from declines in sulfur content, to state biodiesel requirements and low carbon fuel standard programs.

The trial aimed to be realistic in the way change would be made, using existing tanks and equipment, according to Bucher. He noted that did lead to some challenges with water and sludge, which may have needed to be addressed anyway.

NORA also sought to understand any degradation seen over the course of the study, and Bucher highlighted that the fuel quality held up well.

Outside tanks were not used in this study, and Bucher expected the outside tanks would have had gelling issues.

Coldflow properties can vary considerably by manufacturer, and the fuel can be processed to improve coldflow, according to Bucher. However, this additional processing also is dependent upon market demand, because it increases cost.

In an interview on Wednesday, Devine told OPIS that the study demonstrates the evolution of the liquid heating oil industry over the past 25 years, as well as the potential for it to be a notable avenue for decarbonization in the future.

“I think that our industry saw 25 years ago that it needed to make some fundamental changes with regard to the fuel,” Devine said in an interview.

He said the industry’s push over that time to wholly remove the sulfur from heating oil led it to consider biodiesel as an alternate fuel source, which also drew the interest of several states in the Northeast that sought to reduce the emissions from their heating oil industries.

In 2012, New York became the first state in the union to mandate biodiesel blending with heating oil at a 2% rate. That has since increased to 10% and will rise to 20% beginning in 2030.

Connecticut and Rhode Island both have blending mandates on their books as well, with the former at a 10% rate set to increase to 15% by 2030 and the latter at a 20% rate set to increase to 50% by 2030.

These mandates have driven all three states to largely dominate the market, as data from the Energy Information Administration show that New York alone accounted for 57% of all residential and commercial sector biodiesel consumption in the U.S. in 2023.

And they have coincided with a general expansion of the market since 2012, with EIA noting that national consumption of biodiesel for residential and commercial use rose from 1% in 2013 to 5% by 2023.

That expansion has coincided with a series of several approvals over the years from the American Society for Testing and Materials International to allow for higher and higher levels of biodiesel in the standard specification for fuel oils, with the agency moving in April 2026 to approve a spec, ASTM D396-26a, that allows for up to 50% biodiesel in heating applications.

And while Devine noted that some blends have recently performed in the lab setting at a similar level as traditional heating oil, the group still needs to see results from the field to ensure their viability.

In issuing the study, Devine said the group aimed to test both blends of biodiesel and renewable diesel from a “drop-in standpoint” to see whether the blends could perform in certain systems without modifications or alterations to equipment.

“Going into this study, we felt it was important that there was no preparation being done … so there [was] no maintenance of any tanks,” Devine said. “Nothing was cleaned, emptied, or replaced, and there were no modifications to burners.”

Devine said the group specifically sought out as many different types of equipment as possible to use in the study to determine whether equipment choice had any bearing on viability, but the two fuel blends performed “really, really well” across the board.

“The combustion performance remained within the manufacturer’s specifications in the 121 sites,” Devine said. “There was no meaningful increase in fuel-related service events compared to the pre-study baseline.”

Devine did note, however, that the study yielded fuel quality concerns from storage tanks on a site-specific basis – as certain operations struggled with issues like microbial growth in their tanks that affected results.

And other issues remain with offering the fuel blends during the winter, Devine said.

“Just dropping B100 in an outside tank in Maine is not going to be a practical solution today without considering how we are going to solve for cold flow issues,” Devine said.

In traditional heating, he went on to note, issues with cold flow could be resolved by blending in kerosene or additive packages.

“Today, we have come a long way in being able to treat blends of B50 [for cold flow], and they are trying to advance to B100 but we are not quite there yet.”

Overall, Devine said the field study was a success for NORA and its members as a demonstration that the liquid heating oil industry could pivot to offering 100% renewable fuels with these biodiesel and RD blends “as part of a greater solution.”

And while he touched on the pricing concerns surrounding both blends, which run at a premium to traditional heating oil and do not receive similar tax benefits than if they were used for transportation use, Devine said that “markets are going to change” and the decarbonization benefits are notable.

“For example, when we began the field study in January 2024, renewable diesel was probably trading at a dollar more than diesel fuel at that time … and that would make it unaffordable,” Devine said.

“However, if you are looking at it from a carbon intensity standpoint, the investment in these renewable liquid fuels – even at that premium – is still a more cost-effective way to decarbonize than anything else that is out in the energy markets today.”

Reporting by Rachel Stroud-Goodrich, rstroud-goodrich@opisnet.com and Patrick Newkumet, pnewkumet@opisnet.com; Editing by Michael Kelly, mkelly@opisnet.com

 

Categories: Renewables | Tags: Biodiesel / Biofuels