Interview: From Design to Demand β€” How Circularity is Reshaping Product Development

Interview: From Design to Demand β€” How Circularity is Reshaping Product Development

As sustainability commitments and regulatory requirements reshape the global plastics industry, manufacturers are facing increasing pressure to incorporate recycled materials into finished products. However, despite growing interest in circular product design, high production costs, technical limitations and inconsistent recyclate quality continue to constrain demand for recycled plastics.

In the Asia Pacific, the transition is particularly challenging. The prevalence of small and multilayer packaging formats, limited recycling infrastructure and relatively slow regulatory progress have made it difficult for manufacturers to integrate recycled content into existing product designs. Meanwhile, the price premium associated with recycled polymers continues to discourage adoption, particularly in cost-sensitive consumer markets.

While premium product categories β€” including cosmetics, luxury packaging and high-end consumer goods β€” have demonstrated greater willingness to incorporate recycled plastics, broader adoption across fast-moving consumer goods remains largely dependent on regulatory intervention. Increasing scrutiny over sustainability claims is also shifting manufacturers’ attention toward certification, recyclability and independently verified environmental credentials.

In an interview with Dow Jones Energy, Global Strategic Sourcing Manager at Uni-President, Damien Sanjuan, who is also an independent circular economy consultant, discussed how circularity is influencing product development, the challenges of incorporating recycled plastics into finished products, and the regulatory and commercial developments that could shape recycled polymer demand beyond 2027.

(Note: The views expressed in this interview are Sanjuan’s independent perspectives as a circular economy consultant and do not represent the official policies or stances of Uni-President.)

DJE: What are the main challenges manufacturers face when incorporating recycled plastics into finished products?

DS: The primary challenge remains economic. Beyond regulatory requirements, there is currently little commercial or financial incentive for brands to incorporate recycled content into their products.

Technical constraints further complicate adoption, particularly in the Asia Pacific, where small packaging formats and multilayer or barrier packaging are widely used. Incorporating recycled plastics into these applications often requires additional research and development investment.

Manufacturers also continue to face difficulties securing consistent supplies of high-quality, food-grade recycled materials, limiting their ability to integrate recycled content into existing product designs.

DJE: How do companies balance sustainability objectives with production costs and product performance? Are consumers willing to pay a premium for recycled materials?

DS: Β Many companies do not necessarily balance these objectives directly. Instead, they either reposition products toward premium market segments through broader innovation to absorb the additional costs of recycled materials or switch to alternative materials to protect profit margins.

Consumers are generally more willing to pay a sustainability premium when purchasing products already positioned in premium categories, such as luxury goods, cosmetics, fashion and high-end office supplies. In these segments, recycled content can support premium pricing, particularly when combined with attractive product designs and minimal visible changes to material quality.

However, the situation is different for everyday FMCG products. Consumers increasingly regard basic sustainability features, particularly recyclable packaging, as standard expectations rather than attributes that justify higher prices.

Additional sustainability features that require consumers to accept changes in appearance, material characteristics or purchasing behavior, such as greyish recycled packaging or refill systems, may even be expected to come at a discount unless supported by credible environmental certification.

DJE: Are there particular product categories where recycled plastics are gaining greater acceptance? What factors are driving adoption in these applications?

DS: Cosmetics, luxury packaging and high-end consumer goods are currently among the leading categories for recycled plastics adoption.

These sectors typically benefit from stronger profit margins and brand positioning, allowing manufacturers to absorb the additional research, development and material costs associated with recycled polymers.

In premium applications, the appearance and characteristics of recycled materials can also be incorporated into product design and marketed as intentional sustainability features rather than compromises in quality or performance.

DJE: How important are traceability and certification when selecting recycled materials? Have expectations surrounding recycled content verification changed?

DS: The market has undergone a significant shift over the past five to six years. Previously, many FMCG brands placed considerable emphasis on recycled content claims as part of their sustainability strategies. However, growing scrutiny and accusations of greenwashing have weakened the commercial appeal of such claims, regardless of whether they were independently verified. Today, the focus has increasingly shifted toward recognized environmental certifications and third-party verification.

In Europe, for instance, brands are relying more heavily on established green labels, such as the Nordic Swan Ecolabel and A.I.S.E.-related sustainability schemes, as well as retailer-specific requirements to substantiate their environmental claims.

Retailers are also playing a more important role in shaping product sustainability requirements. For example, certification and recyclability assessment frameworks, including RecyClass, are becoming increasingly relevant to manufacturers seeking to demonstrate compliance with retailer expectations.

As a result, certification is becoming an important consideration in product development and market access.

DJE: How are evolving regulations, such as the EU Packaging and Packaging Waste Regulation and extended producer responsibility schemes, influencing product design and material selection?

Damien: In Europe, the PPWR is emerging as a major driver of recycled plastics adoption, with mandatory recycled content thresholds expected to increase demand for compliant materials.

However, progress across the Asia Pacific remains comparatively slow. Regulatory frameworks are still developing in many markets, while extended producer responsibility or EPR schemes are voluntary or at relatively early stages of implementation.

Incomplete recycling infrastructure, particularly across collection, sorting and processing, also makes it difficult for governments to enforce more stringent recycled content obligations.

In parts of the Asia Pacific, for example, many companies have successfully established strong, mature ESG reporting and disclosure frameworks. The industry is currently in a transitional phase, figuring out how to translate those robust reporting metrics into structural product redesigns. Because execution requires highly specialized sustainability engineering expertise that the local market is still actively developing, companies are currently focused on establishing a solid data foundation and finding the right technical partners before rolling out large-scale operational changes.

Looking ahead, Asian regulatory frameworks are likely to draw increasingly from European standards, particularly in packaging. However, more complex requirements, such as digital product passports, may need to be adapted to local data infrastructure and market conditions.

East Asia’s sustainability priorities are also closely linked to its electronics and high-technology industries.

DJE: Are you observing a shift toward designing products specifically for recyclability rather than simply incorporating recycled content? How might this affect demand for different recycled polymer grades?

DS: There is a growing shift toward designing products for recyclability, although progress varies considerably between regions.

In Europe and the U.S., manufacturers face increasing pressure from retailers to demonstrate product recyclability, with non-compliance potentially affecting market access.

At the same time, companies are also pursuing broader carbon footprint reductions, which often favor lightweighting and material reduction rather than simply replacing virgin plastics with recycled alternatives.

Reducing material consumption can offer both environmental and financial benefits, making lightweighting particularly attractive to manufacturers seeking to improve sustainability while controlling costs.

In the Asia Pacific, however, the transition remains at an earlier stage. Recycling infrastructure, consumer readiness and regulatory requirements have not yet developed sufficiently to drive widespread structural redesign of products specifically for recyclability.

DJE: What role does pricing play in decisions between virgin and recycled plastics? Could fluctuations in virgin polymer prices discourage manufacturers from adopting recycled alternatives?

DS: Pricing is not necessarily the primary consideration during the initial product design stage. Manufacturers are accustomed to managing raw material price volatility as part of their procurement strategies. The more important consideration is whether recycled materials can offer a commercially viable alternative to virgin polymers.

If recycled plastics achieved price parity with virgin materials, without significant additional volatility, procurement teams would likely treat them as another conventional sourcing option for applications without major technical constraints.

However, where incorporating recycled materials requires changes to product design, processing or performance specifications, additional research and development costs remain a barrier.

If recycled polymers were consistently cheaper than virgin alternatives, the resulting cost savings could provide a stronger financial justification for manufacturers to invest in overcoming these technical challenges.

DJE: Looking ahead to 2027 and beyond, what developments in product design, consumer preferences or regulation could significantly influence demand for recycled plastics?

DS: The expansion of mandatory EPR frameworks globally is likely to be the strongest driver of recycled plastics demand in the coming years.

As governments introduce more stringent producer responsibility requirements, manufacturers will face increasing pressure to reconsider product design, packaging materials and end-of-life management.

Another important development will be the growing recognition of standardized environmental labels and certifications.

Companies are increasingly highlighting their alignment with the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals and independently verified environmental standards, a trend that is becoming more visible at industry exhibitions and trade shows.

The development of widely recognized and credible product labels could help strengthen consumer confidence, support manufacturers’ sustainability claims and create additional commercial incentives for recycled materials.

By Xin Nee Chua

Categories: Chemicals / Petrochemicals, Renewables | Tags: Plastics & Polymers