Early Data Challenges California’s Proposed Refinery Resupply Rules: CEC

Early Data Challenges California’s Proposed Refinery Resupply Rules: CEC

Preliminary data presented Monday at the California Energy Commission’s Resupply Rulemaking Workshop found no consistent link between isolated planned refinery maintenance and gasoline price increases, suggesting broader market factors may play a role in the state’s supply disruptions.

Signed in 2024, AB X2-1 authorizes the CEC to require refiners to develop resupply plans during planned maintenance outages and maintain minimum inventories of transportation fuels. The legislation also mandated a supply and fuel infrastructure analysis.

William Leung, chief economist in the CEC’s Energy Assessments Division, said preliminary findings call into question whether barrels displaced by planned refinery outages are a primary driver of gasoline price increases at the pump.

“Based on our analysis, we have not yet established a clear relationship between planned maintenance events and (gasoline) prices,” Leung said.

“However, we do see that California-specific price effects are most evident when large planned and unplanned outages occur concurrently.”

Leung also pointed out that refiners generally schedule planned maintenance during the fall, when demand is typically lower, and around seasonal RVP changes.

Refinery “outages and operational disruptions are not rare events,” said Leung.

“They’re a recurring feature of the market, which means any effort to evaluate the relationship to gas prices discounts the fact that disruptions are occurring with some regularity.”

Leung argued that the limited pricing dataset also makes it “difficult” to confidently separate the effects of planned maintenance from the effects of an unplanned disruption on the state’s gasoline prices.

“Many other factors are going to influence gasoline prices, including the seasonal changes in demand, refinery operating costs associated with blending switches and broader crude oil or gasoline market conditions,” Leung said, “though the analysis presented today doesn’t explicitly control for all those factors.”

External market dynamics occurring during a refiner’s maintenance period challenge previous theories that scheduled outages are linked to increased prices at the pump.

“When maintenance events overlap or occur in close succession, it becomes difficult to associate observed price movements with any particular individual event,” Leung said. “Instead, prices may reflect the combined effects of multiple disruptions.”

The agency’s findings also showed some of the periods with the highest levels of statewide refinery maintenance also recorded the smallest increases in the California-U.S. price differential, suggesting maintenance volumes alone may not explain gasoline price movements.

The next phase of research will examine whether market incentives are sufficient to attract additional fuel supplies to California and how market participants respond to changing conditions.

“When prices rise because supplies become tight, market participants have an incentive to bring in additional supply,” Leung said. “When prices fall, they have an incentive to store or purchase the product for future sale. These responses should help moderate price spikes and improve market stability.”

According to Leung, evidence of persistent profitable arbitration could be indicative of potential barriers preventing a “normal” market response.

“These barriers could include transaction costs, logistical constraints, storage limitation, uncertainty or market power,” Leung said.

Leung expressed concern pertaining to the potential barriers and their driving factors, urging the agency to address each potential constraint individually.

“Even if market inefficiencies are identified, a resupply requirement may be an appropriate tool for some barriers, but not others,” Leung said.

Additional research into import supply elasticity and how responsive imported material impacts the California fuels market is still “under development” as the agency works to determine if a resupply requirement would be an appropriate legislative tool for the state’s elevated gasoline prices.

“Understanding that responsiveness is important because it can provide insights into whether existing market mechanisms are effectively addressing supply disruptions, or whether there may be circumstances where additional policy tools could improve supply availability or reduce price volatility,” Leung said.

Gigi Moreno, chief economist in the CEC’s Division of Petroleum Market Oversight, argued that California’s resupply strategy should account for disruptions to the state’s total fuel supply rather than focus narrowly on replacing production lost during an individual refinery’s planned outage.

“If the lost production is offset by supplies from other refiners within the market, it doesn’t change the price impact,” Moreno said, because “the total supply hasn’t changed. All you’ve done is rearranged supply within the market.”

Moreno also pointed to California’s “highly concentrated” gasoline market structure and resupply incentives.

“Unlike in a competitive market, firms with market power know that their individual supply decisions affect prices and affect other firms’ behaviors,” Moreno said.

“They (firms) know they can move the market,” Moreno added.

The CEC extended the public comment period by twelve calendar days to Dec. 4.

Reporting by Sydnee Novak, sydnee.novak@dowjones.com ; Editing by Dean Visser, dean.visser@dowjones.com

Categories: Refined Fuels | Tags: Gasoline