Fiscal Gridlock Fails to Back Global Biodiversity Ambitions at COP17

Fiscal Gridlock Fails to Back Global Biodiversity Ambitions at COP17

The 17th meeting of the Conference of the Parties (COP17) to the United Nations Convention on Biological Diversity took place in Armenia during October. Dow Jones Energy carbon and solar editor Joseph Hoppe interviewed biodiversity consultant Daria Kuznetsova to explore how much progress has been made since COP16 in Columbia two years ago


DJE: COP17 marked the midterm review of the Kunming-Montreal Global Biodiversity Framework (KMGBF) adopted back in 2022. What did that stocktake actually reveal about global progress?
Kuznetsova: It was sobering. The global midpoint review found that almost all of the framework’s targets are failing or severely off track. The only notable exception with a positive score and on track was Target 8, which focuses on minimizing the impacts of climate change and ocean acidification on biodiversity through mitigation, adaptation, and disaster risk reduction. Otherwise, virtually every other area is lagging. Financial targets fared the absolute worst. It appears global biodiversity ambitions are still almost entirely unbacked by fiscal commitments.

DJE: Let’s delve into that finance and the targets. What happened around Target 18 on identifying and reducing harmful subsidies and Target 19 on mobilizing international aid?
Kuznetsova: Targets 18 and 19 are falling drastically short of expectations. Target 18 aims to eliminate or repurpose at least $500 billion annually in harmful, nature-destroying government subsidies by 2030. Yet, the data shows that around 84% of countries that signed have failed to even identify their harmful subsidies by 2025, never mind take any steps to reduce them.

On Target 19 – mobilizing $200 billion annually by 2030, including transferring $20 billion annually from developed to developing countries by 2025 and $30 billion by 2030 to improve biodiversity efforts – funding is just nowhere near where it needs to be. There was intense friction over who should foot the bills.

DJE: What about the Calì Fund established at COP16 [a global UN biodiversity fund that collects contributions from commercial companies that use Digital Sequence Information from nature]? Was there any meaningful progress there?

Kuznetsova: The reality of the CalΓ¬ Fund is almost unbelievable. The mechanism was created so that corporations utilizing genetic sequence data, derived from the benefits of biodiversity – primarily in the pharmaceutical, cosmetic, and agribusiness sectors – would voluntarily contribute a percentage of profits back to biodiversity-rich developing countries [typically 0.1% to 1% of profits].

By the end of COP17, the fund had accumulated just $10,000. When you compare $10,000 to the estimated $700 billion annual biodiversity financing gap, it illustrates the sheer disconnect between international efforts to tackle biodiversity issues and capital flows. Developing nations also sought an independent financial mechanism under the Convention on Biological Diversity, but that proposal was deferred until after 2030.

DJE: You also attended the Business & Biodiversity Forum. What did you observe regarding corporate engagement?
Kuznetsova: It was a bit uninspiring. Companies and financial institutions tended to showcase individual corporate case studies and celebrated small wins rather than confronting hard trade-offs. One notable positive step was a joint letter signed by a group of 130 businesses and financial firms urging governments to accelerate the phase-out of harmful subsidies, but we have to recognize structural incentives. Corporations, particularly fossil fuel and resource extraction companies, are not going to proactively campaign to dismantle the very subsidies that benefit their core business models.

DJE: Nature credits and biodiversity markets apparently generated significant debate. How are they being received by different stakeholders?
Kuznetsova: Nature credits are a deeply polarizing tool. Corporations, financial institutions, and certain governments see them as a viable tool to invite in private capital. However, environmental NGOs and indigenous leaders pretty strongly rejected them.

Critics pointed out that biodiversity is infinitely complex and impossible to commodify into a single fungible unit like, say, the generation of a ton of carbon. The opponents further argue that nature credits lack scalable methodologies, provide opportunities for greenwashing, and divert vital attention away from shutting down destructive subsidies. At the end of the day, the consensus of critics is that it’s better to reduce both harmful subsidies and therefore scale back the need for nature credits, rather than both incentivise to cause and try to fix the problem elsewhere, as it were.

DJE: Amid the gridlock, were there any particularly encouraging outcomes from the summit?

Kuznetsova: The most significant and positive breakthrough was on Indigenous Peoples’ representation and rights under Article 8(j) [an article that requires preserving, maintaining, and promoting the traditional knowledge and practices of indigenous peoples relevant to biodiversity conservation].

Indigenous communities steward roughly 40% of the world’s remaining intact natural ecosystems, but they have historically been sidelined to consultative roles. At COP17, countries agreed on how the new subsidiary body for Article 8(j) would work, including giving Indigenous Peoples and local communities a permanent co-chair position. This gives them a stronger voice in discussions and decisions on biodiversity. Although the final voting power remains with member states, this is an important step towards making environmental decision-making more inclusive and giving Indigenous Peoples a greater role.
Another positive development was the launch of the Friends of Target 18 coalition, co-chaired by Colombia and Finland, alongside the Yerevan Biodiversity Finance Challenge, which offers up to 10 countries $200,000 each in technical support. Together, these initiatives offer countries a way to learn from each other, start tackling environmentally harmful subsidies, and put in place incentives that actually benefit nature. The real test, however, will be whether they can translate these commitments into concrete action.

Categories: Carbon | Tags: Biodiversity