More Than $1 Billion in 45Z Tax Credits Transacted in Two Years: Panel
More than $1 billion in 45Z Clean Fuel Production Tax Credits have been transacted over the past two years, with an estimated half of the deals backed by tax credit insurance, according to Jenny Speck, a partner at Houston-based law firm Vinson & Elkins.
Speaking during a panel at the 18th Annual OPIS RFS, RINs & Biofuels Forum in Chicago last week, Speck said insurance, guarantees and other financial protections can help reassure buyers that they will be compensated if the IRS disallows or reduces purchased credits.
“It’s standard to have an indemnity provision that’s pretty strong in the tax credit purchase agreement,” Speck said. “But when you don’t have a credit rating, a lot of buyers are like, well, how do I know if they’ll have the cash in two or three years? That’s where other forms of providing a backstop are helpful.”
Speck cautioned, however, that tax credit insurance policies are not without limitations, noting that coverage exclusions can leave buyers and sellers exposed to risks. She said renewable fuel producers must understand those exclusions and comply with policy requirements to preserve coverage throughout the transaction process.
“Sometimes these insurance policies are like a warm, cozy blanket that’s been eaten through by moths,” Speck said. “Like on your home or car insurance, there are exclusions on your claim. Tax credit insurance is no different. There’s a long list of exclusions, and you better not do something silly that messes up your policy coverage. I tell our buyers and sellers all the time, yes, this is a good backstop, but it’s not bulletproof.”
Debbie Gordon, principal at RSM US LLP who heads the firm’s energy incentives practice in Washington, D.C., said producers seeking to transfer 45Z credits must document fuel production and sales, obtain third-party verification of carbon intensity scores and demonstrate compliance with applicable prevailing wage requirements to qualify for the full credit rate.
“The buyer of the credit could be any Fortune 100 or 500 C-corp who’s engaged in a completely different business that has no idea what biodiesel or ethanol is,” Gordon said. “They need this full package that’s going to show them how you met all the elements of the credit and that they would be protected because when the buyer puts the tax credit on their own return, it now becomes their tax credit.”
Buyers also typically require tax opinions or memoranda supporting the eligibility and value of credits because they may be subject to IRS audits after claiming them, Gordon said.
Unlike the biodiesel blender’s tax credit (BTC), which expired at the end of 2024 and was generally claimed through the federal excise tax system, 45Z is a performance-based income tax credit for qualifying fuel producers.
Established under the Inflation Reduction Act of 2022 and effective Jan. 1, 2025, the program was subsequently extended through Dec. 31, 2029, under the One Big Beautiful Bill Act (OBBBA) in July 2025. The credit amount depends on emissions performance and applicable labor requirements.
Gordon said the ability to transfer 45Z credits to third-party buyers has expanded monetization opportunities for renewable fuel companies that might otherwise lack sufficient taxable income to use the credits directly.
“Adding in now the ability to transfer these credits really shifted everyone’s mindset on how these credits work,” Gordon said.
In June, the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) issued technical guidelines for measuring feedstock carbon intensity and updated its Feedstock Carbon Intensity Calculator (FD-CIC) for domestically produced corn, soybeans, sorghum and spring canola.
In September, the IRS issued additional guidance on the 45Z emissions rate table, including the treatment of manure-derived fuels and regenerative agricultural practices. Earlier proposed regulations addressed changes enacted under the OBBBA, including the exclusion of indirect land-use change emissions, restrictions on negative emissions rates and limits on eligible feedstock origins.
That month, the Department of Energy (DOE) also released an updated version of its 45Z Clean Fuel Greenhouse Gas Emissions and Energy Use in Transportation (45ZCF-GREET) model, which producers use to calculate lifecycle greenhouse gas emissions associated with qualifying transportation fuels.
More recently, DOE released an Emissions Value Request (EVR) process on Oct. 14, allowing producers whose fuel types, feedstocks or production pathways are not covered by the applicable emissions rate table to request emissions values supporting petitions to the Treasury Department for provisional emissions rates.
The Treasury Department is expected to issue final 45Z regulations in November, according to the Trump administration’s regulatory agenda released July 3. “The baseline is set, but with the new guidance that came out, there are now nuances that everyone is evaluating,” Speck said.
“What can I do to improve my carbon intensity score? What could I be doing to add some investments to the plant that may help increase my credits? Thinking about the new regenerative agricultural practices that have been brought in, how do I bring those into my credit evaluation?” Speck said.
Reporting by Bryan Sims, bsims@opisnet.com; Editing by Patrick Newkumet, pnukumet@opisnet.com
