Shipowners Delay Alternative Fuel Commitments Pending Regulatory Clarity

Shipowners Delay Alternative Fuel Commitments Pending Regulatory Clarity

Shipowners will not commit to alternative marine fuels at scale until the International Maritime Organization (IMO) sets a clear regulatory framework, Jesper Sorensen, global head of alternative fuels and carbon markets at KPI OceanConnect said during a webinar hosted by OPIS on Nov. 12.

Ship owners need certainty of low carbon marine fuel supplies before investing millions of dollars in retrofitting their vessels to operate on dual-fuel engines that can burn conventional fuel or alternate marine fuels. They will not commit to single-fuel engines that run on alternative marine fuel until there is regulatory clarity from the IMO and certainty of supply.

“Owners invest against a clear demand signal, but what they can’t invest against is lack of clarity,” said Sorensen.

Banks are reluctant to fund large projects for green methanol and ammonia production without long-term demand certainty. Several projects have been cancelled due to uncertainty about demand both now and in ten to twenty years’ time.

Anthony Mollet, trading manager at Propeller Fuels and co-founder of the Marine Fuel Alliance (MFA) told webinar viewers that “the problem is also one of credibility with lenders.”

“You’ve got a sizable number of banks in the world that aren’t too keen on the bunker market because of its past history and how checks and systems and processes run,” he said.

“Many ships also do not know where they are going next, so they cannot commit to a single fuel,” Mollet said. “There’s no one [alternative marine fuel] that’s going to rule them all.”

Fuel diversification

Sorensen said that no single alternative marine fuel will dominate the marine fuel mix.

“What works on one trade route might not work on another,” he said. “We are definitely still in the infancy of the green fuel transition,” he said.

Biofuels offer the broadest reach currently because they can be used in existing engines without retrofits, Sorensen added.

KPI OceanConnect, a subsidiary of Bunker Holdings the world’s largest bunker trading company, offers biofuels in more than 220 ports. The price difference between alternative marine fuels and conventional fuels has narrowed over the past year. Biofuel blends B100 can be competitive, and sometimes cheaper, once energy content and compliance costs with FuelEU Maritime and the EU Emissions Trading Scheme (ETS) are added.

“Demand for biofuels has softened this year,” Sorensen said. “One possible reason is the large green credits surplus generated in the regulation’s first year of FuelEU Maritime, which may have reduced the need to buy this year.”

The purpose of FuelEU Maritime is to incentivize the use of low carbon marine fuels to curb emissions in the European Economic Area. The FuelEU Maritime legislation came into force in 2025 and targeted a 2% reduction in greenhouse gas emissions from shipping that year. It increased to 6% in 2026 and is set to drive up to an 80% reduction in greenhouse gas emissions by 2050.

If a ship burns cleaner fuels, such as biofuels or liquefied natural gas (LNG), it earns compliance surplus in the form of extra green credits. If a vessel uses fossil-based conventional marine fuel, it will miss the carbon emissions target and faces heavy fines unless it buys credits from cleaner ships. Last year, many shipping companies used biofuel blends or LNG that easily beat the 2% threshold, generating large amounts of excess green credits. Under the EU rules, a ship can bank or save any leftover credits from last year and apply them toward its 2026 carbon emissions target.

Alternative fuels

Anthony Mollet told webinar attendees that in terms of fuel, “drop-in” does not mean “available on demand.” Spot inquiries, such as a request for fuel in Houston or Malta within a day or two, can be hard to meet because suppliers blend biofuels to specific grades and lead times vary.

“The availability of biofuels is growing, and the volumes in northwest Europe are there,” he said. “But that may be a little bit behind the curve” for ships buying on the spot market.

On quality, Sorensen said suppliers must take responsibility for the fuel they deliver. Industry standards now exist for marine biofuel blends such as B30 and B100. While ethanol as a marine fuel is gaining ground, LNG leads in the vessel order book, as it also has the most developed bunkering infrastructure, both speakers said, with more bunker vessels coming online.

However, some port authorities still refuse to allow LNG supply. Sorensen said one of KPI OceanConnect’s suppliers was denied because the port was close to a naval base.

“Bio-LNG is a credible route for LNG-capable ships. Much of the FuelEU Maritime surplus generated last year came from bio-LNG,” he said.

Methanol as a marine fuel made “meaningful progress,” with ships in service, regular supply in China and licenses granted in Singapore, Sorensen added.

Ethanol has moved “considerably forward” over the past year, with real bunkering experiences, he said. Progress at the IMO, and potentially at EU level, toward approving ethanol as an alternative fuel could change the market again, he said.

Ammonia “needs more work on safety, training and infrastructure before routine commercial use,” according to Mollet. Still, Sorensen said no one should assume they know the end state for 2045 or 2050. “If you go back a good 20 years, I don’t think there were many people talking about ammonia as a potential fuel for ships,” he said.

Trader dynamics

Both speakers agreed the role of traders is changing. Traders can no longer simply trade fuel back-to-back. Now, they need to have knowledge and training of regulatory and compliance requirements.

Bunker Holding set up a “Green Center of Excellence” about five years ago, which has specialists in biofuels, LNG, methanol, ammonia and carbon markets. It runs annual training for traders on the EU ETS and FuelEU Maritime regulations.

Marine fuel suppliers also need certifications such as International Sustainability and Carbon Certification (ISCC) system, management systems and sustainability documentation that is audited and passed along the supply chain, according to Mollet.

“Traders cannot take on customers’ legal compliance duties, but they should own the service and the solutions they provide,” said Sorensen.

Stacy Maphula

Categories: Refined Fuels | Tags: Bunker / Marine Fuels